This story is posted here compliments of, and with permissions of San Jose Mercury News
San Jose Mercury News
Posted on Sat, Dec. 07, 2002
'Enemy Alien' exhibit offers lesson on excess
By Dennis Rockstroh
Before Sept. 11, the date that would live in infamy was Dec. 7.
So a group of authors, scholars and historians have chosen today to open
a photo and artifact exhibit at Berkeley Central Public Library that may
have some lessons worth pondering.
"The Enemy Alien Files: Hidden Stories of World War II'' will run through
The exhibit tells the story of the fear of the enemy that spread rapidly
across the United States after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor.
By evening, the FBI was rounding up hundreds of Japanese, Italian and German
Most people know the story of the roundup of Japanese-Americans, but this
display shows what happened to some of the 31,000 non-citizens who were hauled
off to jail because of their ethnicity.
The enemies then were Japan, Germany and Italy. Today the enemy is not a
nation but shadows around the world.
And over the past year, American citizens, residents and visitors from the
Middle East and South Asia have been rounded up and kept incommunicado.
There is something very un-American about that.
Before Pearl Harbor
In the years before Dec. 7, 1941, it was obvious to American leaders that
there was a possibility that the United States would be drawn into wars in
Asia and Europe.
Government agents watched Japanese, German and Italian immigrants. They drew
up lists of people considered dangerous to be jailed or deported in case
In the exhibit, you will come across people like Filippo Molinari, sales
representative for an Italian newspaper.
``I was the first one arrested in San Jose,'' he said. ``At 11 p.m. three
policemen came to the front door and two at the back. . . . They didn't even
give me time to go to my room and put on my shoes. I was wearing slippers.
They took me to prison.''
In all, more than 30,000 foreigners in the United States and South America
were rounded up. Some were deported. Others were held in camps in Pacifica,
Angel Island, the Great Plains, the Midwest and Texas.
"It was a terrible injustice," Belmont historian John Christgau said. "People
were ripped and torn from their families."
"The only opportunity they had to declare their loyalty was a five-minute
hearing in a camp that was a kangaroo court."
This exhibit raises questions about government action today.
Because the sad fact is that the federal government has a sorry history of
leading the nation into trouble and, sometimes, disaster.
Professor David Cole discussed the current legal implications this year in
the Stanford Law Review.
``There is undoubtedly a balance to be struck between liberty and security,
but there are also several reasons to be cautious about too readily sacrificing
liberty in the name of security. First, as a historical matter, we have overreacted
in times of crisis.
``In hindsight, these responses are generally viewed as shameful excesses;
but, in their day, they were considered reasonable and necessary,'' he said.
``The post-Sept. 11 response constitutes a reprise of some of the worst mistakes
of the past,'' he concluded. ``Once again, we are treating people as suspicious
not for their conduct, but based on their racial, ethnic or political identity.
``Once again, we are using the immigration power as a pretext for criminal
law enforcement, and we have undertaken a mass detention campaign directed
at immigrants without probable cause that any of them are tied to specific
threats that we face.''
The exhibit is an important lesson on excess. And as one descendant of a
jailed immigrant said recently, ``If the story isn't told soon, pretty soon
nobody will know it happened.''
The Berkeley library is at 2090 Kittredge St. For more information, call
Contact Dennis Rockstroh at email@example.com or (510) 790-7304.